ES 'शाश्वतता के विरुद्ध नियम' की व्याख्या कीजिए तथा इस नियम के अपवादों का विश्लेषण कीजिए।

Rule Against Perpetuity: Meaning, Application, and Exceptions

1. Meaning of Rule Against Perpetuity

The Rule Against Perpetuity is a legal principle that prevents property from being tied up indefinitely for future generations. It ensures that property remains transferable and economically useful rather than being locked away for an uncertain period.

Legal Provision (Section 14, Transfer of Property Act, 1882)

"No transfer of property can create an interest that takes effect after the lifetime of one or more living persons at the time of transfer, plus a further period of eighteen years."

Objective of the Rule

• Ensures free transferability of property.
• Prevents excessive restrictions on property ownership.
• Avoids uncertainty in legal transactions.

---

2. Essentials of the Rule Against Perpetuity

For a transfer to violate this rule, it must involve:

1. Creation of a Future Interest – The transfer must involve delayed ownership for an unborn person.
2. Time Limit Exceeding a Life + 18 Years – Property cannot be restricted from transfer beyond the lifetime of a living person plus 18 years (the time when an unborn person attains majority).
3. Uncertainty of Vesting – If the interest is too remote or uncertain, the transfer is void.

---

3. Exceptions to the Rule Against Perpetuity

The rule does not apply in the following cases:

(i) Transfers for Public Benefit (Charitable or Religious Purposes)

• If property is transferred for public welfare, education, or religious use, the rule does not apply.
• Example: A gift of land for constructing a hospital is valid indefinitely.

(ii) Personal Agreements (Contracts and Pre-Emptive Rights)

• If a contract gives a right of first refusal to purchase a property in the future, it is not restricted by the rule.
• Example: A tenant’s pre-emptive right to buy the leased property.

(iii) Covenants and Restrictive Agreements

• Land use restrictions (e.g., only residential construction allowed) are valid indefinitely.

(iv) Lease Agreements

• Perpetual leases (e.g., 99-year leases) are enforceable as they do not transfer ownership.

(v) Government Grants and Transfers

• Property granted by the government is exempt from the rule against perpetuity.

(vi) Hindu Joint Family Property

• Hindu Undivided Family (HUF) property is passed down generations by survivorship, and the rule does not apply.

---

4. Judicial Interpretation

Stanley v. Leigh (1732)

• The court held that property cannot be tied up indefinitely and should be available for economic use.

Girjesh Dutt v. Datadin (1934)

• The Privy Council ruled that a transfer in favor of an unborn person without a prior life interest to a living person is void.

---

5. Conclusion

The Rule Against Perpetuity (Section 14, TPA) prevents indefinite restrictions on property transfer. However, charitable transfers, government grants, leases, and contractual rights are exempt. This ensures a balance between protecting property rights and maintaining economic flexibility.