ES किन परिस्थितियों में किसी डिक्री के निष्पादन में निर्णीत ऋणी को गिरफ्तार और दीवानी जेल में निरुद्ध किया जा सकता है?

Arrest and Detention of a Judgment Debtor for Execution of a Decree

The judgment debtor is the person against whom a court has passed a decree, requiring them to pay money or perform an obligation. If the judgment debtor fails to comply with the decree, the decree-holder (the person in whose favor the decree is passed) can seek execution through arrest and detention in civil prison under Order XXI, Rules 37-40 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (CPC).

However, arrest and detention are not the first remedies; they are used only in exceptional circumstances.

---

Circumstances Under Which a Judgment Debtor Can Be Arrested and Detained

A judgment debtor may be arrested and detained if any of the following conditions apply:

1. Intention to Obstruct or Delay Execution (Order XXI, Rule 37 CPC)

• If the judgment debtor has the means to pay but intentionally delays or obstructs execution, they can be detained in civil prison.
• The decree-holder must provide evidence of deliberate non-compliance.

2. Fraudulent Transfer or Concealment of Property (Section 51 & Order XXI, Rule 40 CPC)

• If the judgment debtor fraudulently transfers, conceals, or disposes of property to avoid payment, they can be detained.
• The court will examine evidence to determine whether assets were hidden with the intent to defraud creditors.

3. Willful Refusal to Pay Despite Having Means (Section 51 CPC)

• If the judgment debtor has sufficient financial means but refuses to pay the decretal amount, the court can order detention.
• The burden of proof lies on the decree-holder to establish that the debtor has the capacity to pay.

4. Judgment Debtor’s Bad Faith Conduct (Order XXI, Rule 40 CPC)

• If the debtor dishonestly refuses to comply or acts in bad faith, detention may be ordered.
• Example: If the debtor is leading a lavish lifestyle while claiming financial incapacity.

5. Non-compliance with Court’s Order to Show Cause (Order XXI, Rule 37 CPC)

• The court first issues a show cause notice to the judgment debtor, asking why they should not be arrested.
• If the debtor fails to appear or does not provide a valid reason, the court may order arrest.

---

Procedure for Arrest and Detention in Civil Prison

1. Filing of Application

   • The decree-holder applies to the court for execution by arrest and detention.

2. Issuance of Show Cause Notice (Order XXI, Rule 37 CPC)

   • The court issues a notice to the debtor, requiring them to appear and explain why they should not be arrested.

3. Hearing and Inquiry (Order XXI, Rule 40 CPC)

   • The court examines whether the judgment debtor has means to pay but refuses to do so.
   • Evidence from both parties is considered.

4. Court’s Decision

   • If the court finds that the debtor is intentionally defaulting, it may order detention.
   • If the debtor proves genuine financial hardship, the court may grant time for payment.

5. Period of Detention (Section 58 CPC)

   • Maximum period:
     • 3 months if the decree is for an amount above ₹5000.
     • 6 weeks if the decree is for an amount between ₹2000 - ₹5000.
   • No detention if the decree is for less than ₹2000.

---

Exceptions: When Arrest and Detention Cannot Be Ordered

1. If the Judgment Debtor is a Woman (Section 56 CPC)

   • Women cannot be arrested and detained for non-payment of a civil decree.

2. If the Debtor is a Minor or an Elderly Person

   • Courts generally avoid detaining minors or elderly individuals unable to earn.

3. If the Debtor is Facing Genuine Financial Hardship

   • If the debtor proves that they truly lack resources, they cannot be detained.

4. If the Decree is for Payment of Money from a Contract of Employment (Prohibition against forced labor - Article 23 of the Indian Constitution).

---

Conclusion

• Arrest and detention of a judgment debtor is a last resort and not a routine execution method.
• It is applicable only when the debtor fraudulently evades payment, conceals assets, or willfully refuses to pay despite having the means.
• The court ensures due process before ordering detention, protecting debtors from unfair imprisonment while ensuring decree-holders get justice.