ES वे कौन-सी दशायें हैं जिसके अनुसार स्थावर सम्पत्ति का पट्ट्टा पर्यवसित (समाप्त) हो सकता है? विस्तार से वर्णन कीजिए।

Determination of Lease of Immovable Property

A lease is a contract where the owner (lessor) grants the right to use immovable property to another person (lessee) for a specified period in exchange for rent or consideration. The termination of a lease is known as "determination of lease", and it is governed by Section 111 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 (TPA).

---

1. Conditions for Determination of Lease (Section 111, TPA)

According to Section 111, a lease can be determined in the following ways:

(i) By Lapse of Time (Section 111(a))

• If a lease is created for a fixed term (e.g., 5 years), it automatically expires when the time period ends.
• No separate notice is required unless the contract specifies otherwise.
• Example: If a shop is leased for 3 years, it terminates automatically after 3 years.

(ii) By Happening of a Specified Event (Section 111(b))

• If a lease is contingent upon the occurrence of a future event, it terminates when that event happens.
• Example: A lease is granted until the lessee gets married; once he marries, the lease ends.

(iii) By Termination of Interest of Lessor (Section 111(c))

• If the lessor loses ownership of the property, the lease also terminates.
• Example: If a landlord sells the property or if the government acquires it for public use, the lease ends.

(iv) By Merger of Interests (Section 111(d))

• If the lessee becomes the owner of the property, the lease automatically merges with ownership and ends.
• Example: If a tenant buys the rented property, the lease merges into ownership.

(v) By Express Surrender (Section 111(e))

• The lease ends if the lessee voluntarily gives up possession and surrenders the lease to the lessor.
• Example: A tenant returns the keys and vacates the premises before the lease term expires.

(vi) By Implied Surrender (Section 111(f))

• Surrender can also happen impliedly, such as when:
  • The lessee takes a new lease from the landlord, replacing the old lease.
  • The lessee abandons the property, and the landlord takes possession.

(vii) By Forfeiture (Section 111(g))

• The lessor can terminate the lease if the lessee:
  • Breach of lease conditions – If the lessee violates the terms of the lease (e.g., subletting without permission).
  • Denies the lessor’s ownership – If the tenant claims ownership of the property.
  • Non-payment of rent – If the lessee fails to pay rent within the agreed time.
• Notice is required for forfeiture, except in cases of express contractual agreements.

(viii) By Notice to Quit (Section 111(h))

• A lease without a fixed period (month-to-month, year-to-year) can be terminated by notice.
• The duration of the notice period depends on the type of lease:
  • For monthly lease – 15 days’ notice is required.
  • For yearly lease – 6 months’ notice is required.

(ix) By Insolvency of the Lessee (Section 111(i))

• If the lessee is declared insolvent and the lease agreement prohibits continued possession, the lease ends.
• Example: A business tenant declared bankrupt may lose his right to continue under the lease.

---

2. Additional Ways a Lease Can Be Terminated

(i) By Eviction Under Rent Control Laws

• In cases where the tenant is protected under rent control laws, eviction is allowed only on specific grounds like:
  • Non-payment of rent.
  • Misuse of property.
  • Landlord's need for personal use.

(ii) By Agreement Between the Parties

• The landlord and tenant can mutually agree to terminate the lease at any time.

---

3. Legal Consequences of Lease Determination

1. Lessee must vacate the property – If the lease is terminated, the tenant must hand over possession.
2. Lessor can file a suit for eviction – If the lessee refuses to vacate, the lessor can file a case for eviction.
3. Liability for Rent and Damages – If the lessee overstays, he may have to pay rent at a higher rate.

---

4. Conclusion

A lease can be determined automatically (expiration, event, merger) or by legal action (forfeiture, eviction, notice). Section 111 of the TPA ensures that lease termination is fair and legally enforceable, balancing the rights of both landlords and tenants.